solar vs wind

Solar energy vs. wind energy: which is right for you?

Installing a renewable energy system on your property is one of the best ways to save money on your electricity bills while reducing your impact on the environment. Often, your decision will be between solar energy and wind energy. If you’re a homeowner weighing your renewable energy options, you already know that thorough research is the best way to find the right system for your home. Here’s everything you need to know about the benefits of residential wind vs. solar so that you can make your decision with confidence.

Solar vs. wind quick hits

  • In general, solar makes much more sense for residential electricity customers looking to save money
  • Wind power is an effective tool for utilities looking to source more energy from reliable renewables
  • Property owners can compare solar quotes on the EnergySage Marketplace to see how much you can save

The big takeaway: solar makes more sense for residential properties

If you’re interested in installing a renewable energy system on your property, solar is usually the best option. All things considered, solar isn’t as popular as wind at the utility scale, but is generally a more practical renewable option for residential energy production. An experiment by Inland Power & Light, a utility in the Pacific Northwest, underscores the comparative benefits of residential solar. After fielding many inquiries about the benefits of solar vs. wind energy for homes, the utility actually installed both technologies at their corporate headquarters in Spokane, Washington to provide a definitive answer to their customers. Their result: Over the course of 14 months, the solar panels produced about five times as much electricity as the wind turbine.

Wind vs. solar: comparing the top renewables

In the United States, wind power is significantly more popular than solar. Out of all the renewable energy produced in the U.S. in 2019, 24% came from wind, while 9% came from solar power. Utilities and large scale operations heavily utilize wind energy while homeowners prefer solar energy.

The primary benefit of wind over solar power for your home is that wind turbines aren’t dependent on sunlight. This means that they have the ability to generate power 24 hours a day, whereas solar panels only generate power during sunlight hours. Wind comes with a significant caveat, however: in order to be effective, wind turbines need to be situated high above any obstacles that would block the wind.

A typical wind turbine for residential use is about 80 feet tall, and it needs to be in the path of some serious wind to produce power efficiently. Most installers recommend sites with average wind speeds of at least 12 miles per hour. If you live in a rural, windy area with lots of open space and few obstructions blocking the wind’s path, then installing wind turbines at your property can be a great option for renewable energy production. If you’re looking for a supplementary power source, rather than a primary one, you can also find smaller wind turbines at a relatively low cost that will provide an extra ‘boost’ of electricity.

In contrast, solar panels can be installed on almost any roof, as well as on the ground, and still produce enough power to meet the majority of your electricity needs. In the EnergySage Solar Marketplace, the average solar shopper meets over 95 percent of their annual electricity needs with solar in 2021.

Wind turbines also have moving parts, which can result in more wear-and-tear and higher maintenance requirements. Unless you choose ground-mounted solar panels with a tracking system (a technology generally reserved for utility solar installations), your solar PV system will be stationary and require limited maintenance.

What about renewable options other than solar and wind?

There’s no reason that a solar panel system has to be the renewable energy that you use in your home. Solar thermal technology, which can provide both heat and hot water for your home, is often installed alongside solar PV. If you’re looking for a renewable heating and cooling system to pair with your solar panels, you can also install a geothermal heat pump to use the naturally existing heat underground to regulate the temperature of your home.

Compare all of your options before making a decision

Whatever renewable energy option you’re considering, it’s always a good idea to before making a final decision. Solar can save you thousands on your electricity bills. Want to see for yourself? Check out EnergySage’s Solar Calculator to get an instant estimate of how much solar could save you. Once ready, compare quotes from solar installers on the EnergySage Solar Marketplace to find the best deal. Solar shoppers in the Marketplace generally save up to 25 percent off the costs of installing a solar panel system simply by shopping around first. There’s no better way to go solar.

This post originally appeared on Mother Earth News.

low cvr content
environmental content

14 thoughts on “Solar energy vs. wind energy: which is right for you?

  1. Iyiola Mobolaji Adigun.

    Well I believe in solar energy systems, as well as the wind mill energy supply….. Mostly in Africa Nigeria ,there is alot of sun shine bright radiation and there is no electricity in the region,the failure of the old kanji dam, This is an old system in the scientific knowledge of the world,,apart from that my nation is naturally endowed with crude oil and gas, and all is on exploits to no ability of resource… I believe in solarium…source of energy…..The Sun…..

  2. hydrogen production

    boundaries for needs first, it is going to just put more money in foreign oil pockets
    and may have little effect on our retail prices.
    Set the panels up plus they convert sunlight to electric power, plug and
    play real simple. This all very commendable but
    following your day in the end you be repaying for your energy use unless you consider the bull
    by the horns and invest in your own home solar power system.

  3. Kyrie2516

    Light conditions in the Northwest East of the Cascade Mountains are far sunnier than West of the Cascades. How much more efficient are combining wind and solar energy sources for low sun areas of the country? Are there any specific reasons why to only choose one or the other and/or both concurrently?

  4. J C

    We should all be striving for renewable energy self sufficiency off the grid .. to stop the use of fossil fuels… bring on the cheaper storage batteries

  5. JC

    Some people don’t know that optimal temperature for solar is 70°,anything above that will cause it to have less production of power of the actual solar cell (this is for those who think the desert is better for solar)


    I live in New Jersey where they currently are offering WIND POWER through a POWER PARTNERSHIP COMPANY where the power is produced from a wind farm in another part of the country to deliver my power. I signed up today. WHY ? I dont have to invest in the turbines or solar panels or worry about maintenance, parts, equipment breakdowns and the like. Something for a lot of home owners to look into.

    1. Jamie Hill

      If your power provider is like ours here in upstate NY your green power option only applies what you pay them to their overall percentage of green energy production and profit. Ours has nothing to do with the actual energy source that’s piped into our homes.

  7. jresquival

    I didn’t know that 19% of all the power in the U.S. was generated by wind. That must be because we have a lot of mountains in the country. Wind power works best when you have a higher elevation and a clear area.

    1. Brianna Marie Ellison

      Yeah, I live in Idaho and I used to live in Iowa and both places have a lot of wind turbines. The mid west and Rockies are very windy and good for turbines.

      1. -Insert Name Here-

        I see what you mean, but in places like Nevada solar energy is a better option because of the summer heat.

    2. Big Jack

      You read it wrong. The author of the article stated that 19% of all RENEWABLE (and NOt total) energy came from wind. The author did not mention was percentage it was versus the total energy.

    3. Farmer Leon

      Please read again….not 19% all power in the US is generated by wind. It states of all the renewable energy sources (ie geothermal, wind, hydroelectric, solar) wind provides 19%. Take into consideration that of the % total energy consumed in the US about 5 to 7 percent comes from renewable energy sources.


Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.